Some Friendly competition: Voting thread Round 1

I decided to do it like this, seperated into two different rounds

No voting for the match you are in...just to be fair.
Match one:

A:

B:

MAtch Two:

C:

D :

ALright voting system:

Effects: 1-10
Flow: 1-20
Stock usage: 1-20

Match 2:

C: 14/ 7/ 12

the effects masked the stock too much for Smiley Face (C:) and spreads out interest points to the entire stock, decreasing the value of the parts that should be focused on.

D: 14/12/17

The sparkle effect somewhat masks the full extent of the stock, as well as the stock not seeming to fit with the effects in places (and the little squiggle in the bottom left of the green smoke thing looking out of place)

D: sara could you use the letters instead, it'll make it a lot easier to tell whom your voting for.

could you show picture frowny face?

Sorry, but i forgot to but this in; voting for yourself is not allowed. So, Sarad please change edit out your vote for yourself. I want to make it fair. So only vote for the match your not involved in.

Match one:
A: effects:2
Flow:6
Stock Usage:10
- Im sorry, but this one lacks flow, the effects are basic, and could be way better :\

B:
Effects: 6
Flow: 16
Stock Usage: 13
- Effects, flow, and the stock usage are great, i love the vibe i am getting from it. the colors are a bit contrasted, but that can easily be fixed ^_^.

Match one:

B: Effects:8/10 I love the eploding effects on the tag. It creates a big effect on it.
Flow: 9/10 I can definately see where you;re going there.
Stock usage: 10. :/ Im a little iffy on the stock But it's been used quite well.

A: Effects: 5/10 It's basic but im sure you could've done more. c: Like smudging.
Flow: 3/10 Sorry mate, but I can't seem to tell where the direction is. D:
Stock usage: 8/10 Nice choice but the clothes blends in with the effects. But it's a ninja after all.

Sir Raito wrote:

Match one:

B: Effects:8/10 I love the eploding effects on the tag. It creates a big effect on it.
Flow: 9/10 I can definately see where you;re going there.
Stock usage: 10. :/ Im a little iffy on the stock But it's been used quite well.

A: Effects: 5/10 It's basic but im sure you could've done more. c: Like smudging.
Flow: 3/10 Sorry mate, but I can't seem to tell where the direction is. D:
Stock usage: 8/10 Nice choice but the clothes blends in with the effects. But it's a ninja after all.

where would smudging help it?

Saradamon Lanaldor wrote:

Sir Raito wrote:

Match one:

B: Effects:8/10 I love the eploding effects on the tag. It creates a big effect on it.
Flow: 9/10 I can definately see where you;re going there.
Stock usage: 10. :/ Im a little iffy on the stock But it's been used quite well.

A: Effects: 5/10 It's basic but im sure you could've done more. c: Like smudging.
Flow: 3/10 Sorry mate, but I can't seem to tell where the direction is. D:
Stock usage: 8/10 Nice choice but the clothes blends in with the effects. But it's a ninja after all.

where would smudging help it?

With the right direction, and different ways of smudging, it would produce a great look, and provide more depth.

fjkghljkfghkldf

YOU BEAT ME TO IT.

What he said c:

It also makes pretty effects.

but it's infinite! (that is actually a mathematical function that i used, it makes an infiitely repeating pattern)

if i smudged it, it would be finite!

Winner VS Winner I guess

and

Runner up VS Runner up.

I dunno.